The preceding essay on LCA and institutions examined the relationship between methods and regulation. Here I want to return to a more concrete question for manufacturers: when a customer asks for environmental data, what should happen first?
The earlier version tried to map a path from zero to an EPD. But it arranged CBAM, product carbon footprints, EPDs, and marketing requirements into one shared staircase, as though completing an EPD would unlock every next step. That tidy route can lead people to spend money on the wrong work.
I would now start with a different question: Who will receive this data, what will they use it for, and which version will they use to accept it? Establish those three things first. Then decide which product to assess, which rules to follow, and what to deliver.
Define the deliverable before naming the project
LCA, product carbon footprints, and EPDs may all appear in one meeting. Their purposes differ.
| Name | Main question it answers | What to establish before starting |
|---|---|---|
| Life cycle assessment, or LCA | What potential environmental impacts does the product have within the defined life cycle and methodology? | Is the purpose comparison, improvement, or support for a particular disclosure? |
| Product carbon footprint | How is the product’s climate-change impact quantified? | What are the unit, life-cycle scope, and customer specifications? |
| Environmental product declaration, or EPD | How should verified product environmental information be disclosed under the applicable rules? | Which programme, PCR, and verification arrangement will be accepted? |
| Data required for CBAM | What are the embedded emissions and related declaration conditions for covered imports? | Which goods, who declares, and which calculation and verification rules apply? |
ISO 14067’s public description limits product carbon footprints to the climate-change impact category. An EPD is an environmental information declaration based on life cycle assessment. Having one carbon number is not the same as having completed an EPD.
The EU’s CBAM guidance addresses specific covered goods and declarants’ obligations. Its definitive regime began in January 2026. An EPD does not automatically replace a CBAM declaration, and it is not a universal passport for exports. How much underlying data can be reused still requires a field-by-field comparison of boundaries, methods, and acceptance requirements.
Establish who will accept the results before choosing rules
If the buyer does require an EPD, I would first put its requested programme, product scope, version, and deadline on a one-page confirmation sheet, then choose a programme operator and PCR.
PCR means product category rules: the rules for calculating and presenting environmental information for that category. The International EPD System’s development process requires an applicable PCR that is valid at verification, together with a complementary PCR where required. These are that programme’s rules; they should not be presented as identical across every programme worldwide.
It makes little sense to buy software and download a roughly matching PCR, only to ask months later whether the customer recognizes it.
My confirmation sheet would specify the product and covered plants, declared or functional unit, life-cycle stages, PCR and complementary-rule versions, verification arrangements, output format, and whether the receiving party accepts the programme. If no suitable PCR exists, discuss the available path with the operator. Do not rename another category’s rules and apply them yourself.
Versions also need more than a memory of an old essay. ISO now lists ISO 14025:2026, while the 2006 edition’s page marks it as withdrawn. How a particular EPD programme adopts the new edition, including transition arrangements, still needs confirmation with the operator. A new edition does not mean every existing project changes requirements on the same day.
Organize data around one product, not the whole company
This brings me to the part of the original essay I most want to retain: data must be traceable to a person, a time, and a product.
Start with a boundary diagram: which materials enter, where processing happens, what energy is used, and what is produced? Which transport, use, and end-of-life stages belong inside the assessment? Scope follows the purpose and applicable rules. Do not silently omit a stage because data is difficult to obtain, or apply construction-product module names to every industry.
Then establish the unit. “One kilogram of material” and “one product providing specified performance over a stated period” do not necessarily answer the same question. The intended comparison affects the definition at the start.
At a minimum, I would keep the following in the data inventory:
- Quantities, units, data periods, and how plants and products are linked.
- Electricity, fuels, raw materials, packaging, transport, and other inputs and outputs within scope.
- How energy and other inputs are allocated when products share a line, and why that method is used.
- Which measurements, supplier data, or background-database records are used, with versions and reasons for selection.
- Gaps, estimates, uncertainties, who will resolve them, and how they will be disclosed.
Organizational electricity or fuel totals can be a starting point. They do not become a product result without further work. Selecting a background record labeled “Taiwan” or “global average” is not enough either. Its technology, geography, period, and model must fit the task.
The earlier essay stated cut-off thresholds, allocation-effect percentages, and data periods too generally. I have removed the fixed percentages. Those choices should follow the applicable method and PCR, with reasons and sensitivity checks recorded.
A verified EPD still leaves comparison and claims to address
Data collection, modeling, declaration preparation, independent verification, registration, and publication form a traceable workflow. EPD International describes an EPD as transparent, third-party-verified environmental information. It does not automatically guarantee a greener product.
Comparison requires another step. Product function and performance, units, life-cycle scope, rules, and impact-assessment methods need to align. Two EPDs alone cannot establish “ours is 30% lower.” Having the same verifier does not replace those comparability conditions. Guidance on EPD comparability
Marketing adds a further layer. The International EPD System’s September 2026 communication guidance distinguishes a neutral EPD document from its use in advertising. The programme logo identifies the programme; it should not be treated as a badge declaring a product greener or endorsed.
Seen this way, verification has a concrete value: others can follow the data and rules behind your statement. It cannot endorse every advertising claim added afterward.
Check regulations individually instead of turning forecasts into a fixed timeline
The earlier essay predicted that the Green Claims Directive would pass in 2026 and take effect in 2028. It also called an EPD a “legal qualification for marketing.” Those statements need to be withdrawn.
As checked on November 3, 2026, the European Parliament’s procedure page still listed the proposal as awaiting the Council’s first-reading position. That cannot be presented as a settled legislative timetable. Meanwhile, EU consumer rules already address misleading environmental claims. An unfinished proposal does not mean marketing is unconstrained.
CBAM, battery rules, product ecodesign, and sustainability disclosure likewise have their own subjects, conditions, and progress. I no longer arrange them into an EPD calendar that every manufacturer must follow step by step.
A more useful applicability checklist identifies the product, destination market, responsible party, effective regulation or customer document, and relevant version and date. Mark proposals, planned measures, and effective obligations separately. Ask the appropriate professional to confirm product-specific judgments.
Break down the work before estimating budget and schedule
“Eight to eighteen months” and “NT$500,000 to NT$5 million” may look useful for budgeting, but the original essay supplied no reconstructable sample or scope. I will not keep presenting them as generally applicable market ranges.
I would ask separate questions. Whose time does internal data preparation require? What do modeling and consulting services include? How long can software and background data be used, and can they be handed over? Who quotes external verification, registration, annual fees, and later updates?
For example, EPD International’s pricing page separates registration and annual fees, with different arrangements in some regions. It is not the total price of a project from data collection through verification. EPD Danmark also distinguishes LCA preparation, verification, and publication-related costs. Compare the scope of quotations before comparing their totals.
Work backward from the delivery date. Have the applicable rules been confirmed? Who will close data gaps? When can the verifier review the work? How will revisions after rejection be handled? Without answers, a range of months is not a project guarantee.
From the first project meeting, I would most want to take away four things: a deliverable specification accepted by the buyer, a product-boundary diagram, a data-gap list with named owners, and arrangements for verification and subsequent updates.
An EPD’s value can begin there. The company does more than hand over a report: when a process or supplier changes, it still knows which numbers need another look, who will update them, and what supports its public statements.


💬 Comments
Loading...