Can a company decide where to operate by asking which place has more “order”?

I like using order as a reminder: Are processes clear? Can commitments be kept? When something goes wrong, can we find the person responsible? But a real decision requires breaking those questions down. An elegant term from physics cannot replace an investigation.

In this essay, “moving closer to negentropy” is my management metaphor. It is not a physical score calculated for the United States, China, or any other place. It does not automatically tell a business to leave or stay.

TL;DR: The second law of thermodynamics concerns entropy in physical systems; it cannot directly rank institutions or companies. The original article confused closed and isolated systems, which I correct here. Disorder in a room, codebase, or relationship is not a thermodynamic measurement made in this essay. For Taiwanese businesses, I suggest replacing “order” with questions about contracts, rule changes, data and technology rights, business continuity, and exit conditions. This is my analytical approach, not a ranking of countries or a universally optimal strategy.

1. Keep physical definitions within their scope

An isolated thermodynamic system exchanges neither matter nor energy with its surroundings. A closed system exchanges no matter but can exchange energy. These terms are not interchangeable.[1]

An explanation of the second law must account for the total entropy of the system and its surroundings: it remains unchanged in a reversible process and increases in an irreversible one.[2] The original claims that “entropy only increases in a closed system” and that “without external energy, collapse is inevitable” were therefore oversimplified.

Entropy has a specific physical definition. “I think this company is chaotic” is not itself a thermodynamic measurement. Cleaning a room, maintaining code, and caring for relationships can illustrate a metaphor, but they are not physical experiments conducted in this essay.

I will keep the reminder that the metaphor offers without allowing it to lend the authority of a scientific law to the business claims that follow.

2. The second law cannot score institutional risk for us

The original article called the United States a center of negentropy and described risks in China as pressure from increasing entropy. The problem was more than forceful wording: it placed different institutions on a single scale without establishing a common measure or providing the data.

I no longer retain that ranking, nor infer from physics that the United States, Japan, and Europe offer the best protection for core assets. A comparison must address actual conditions in a particular country, period, industry, and transaction, rather than begin by deciding who represents order.

The World Bank’s Worldwide Governance Indicators distinguish multiple dimensions of governance and caution that aggregate indicators are often too broad for specific reforms or diagnoses, which need more detailed information.[3] They offer a starting point for inquiry, not sufficient backing for a particular company’s investment decision. I have not retrieved and compared country scores for China and the United States, or completed a geopolitical risk rating.

If “choosing the side of order” remains useful, it should mean looking for conditions we can verify, rather than giving a position a scientific name.

3. Turn order into four sets of questions

When a company evaluates where to operate, I would begin with four sets of questions:

  • Contracts: Who promises what? How will delivery be accepted? What avenues exist to resolve a dispute and enforce an agreement?
  • Rules: Who tracks applicable requirements? How are changes communicated? Which changes trigger a reassessment?
  • Rights: Who holds the data, technology, and outputs? Can they be transferred or recovered? Where do the licensing boundaries lie?
  • Business continuity: If a critical dependency fails, who can take over, how long will it take, and what will exiting cost?

These are my starting questions, not legal advice or a validated risk scorecard. People familiar with the transaction and jurisdiction still need to check the actual terms and applicable requirements.

I will not fill in missing margins, customer details, or technology-transfer arrangements from the component-industry dinner mentioned in the original article. Without corresponding records, one conversation cannot answer location questions for every business.

Rather than asking “Which side are you on?”, I would ask: Which conditions are confirmed, and which are merely hoped for?

Four-panel comic: Can a company decide where to operate by asking which place has more “order”? Who promises what? How will delivery be accepted? What avenues exist to resolve a dispute and enforce an agreement? Who tracks applicable requirements? How are changes communicated? Which changes trigger a reassessment? Who holds the data, technology, and outputs? Can they be transferred or recovered? Where do the licensing boundaries lie? If a critical dependency fails, who can take over, how long will it take, and what will exiting cost? A metaphor can help us begin asking questions; ultimately, we must return to what can be verified.

4. Two locations may still share one dependency

Diversification is worth evaluating, but a “dual-base” strategy is not always the best prescription. A second location adds setup, management, and coordination costs. If both locations rely on the same critical supplier, they may be affected together.

These are possibilities to examine, not country-level supply risks measured in this essay. Decision-makers need to map their actual dependencies to understand what an additional address diversifies.

Similarly, describing international capital-market rules as more predictable is not enough to establish that a particular financing, listing, or ownership arrangement is safer. Duration, rights, use of funds, and exit terms require separate checks.

My suggestion is to ask each alternative the same questions: What costs does it add? Which dependency does it reduce? Which risks remain shared? Mark anything without supporting information as unconfirmed.

5. Order also means acknowledging limits and allowing revision

A comprehensive procedure does not guarantee that people follow it. Having a contractual clause does not prove the ability to perform. This is the practical perspective I want to retain when I use the word “order.”

To apply the approach in management, I would record sources, confirmation dates, responsible people, and conditions for the next review. New facts should be allowed to change a judgment, rather than be excluded because they do not fit the original metaphor.

We can also ask concrete questions about collaboration: Do we understand each other’s expectations? Can we discuss disagreements? Is there a way to repair things when they go wrong? None of this requires labeling someone a “negentropic person” or a “source of chaos.”

These are practical suggestions from the author. They do not guarantee business survival, investment returns, or a better personal life.

6. Move closer to commitments that can be checked

I still value the direction of making things more orderly: fewer unclear responsibilities, more inspectable records, and clearer conditions before important choices.

But order need not mean permanence or the exclusion of discussion, innovation, and disagreement. Seeking only surface agreement can make problems harder to see.

I will not use thermodynamics to choose a country for your business, or physical terminology to characterize people you work with. What I can offer is a grounded habit: understand dependencies, check commitments, and leave room for future revisions.

A metaphor can help us begin asking questions; ultimately, we must return to what can be verified.

Sources and scope of reading (checked through November 4, 2026)

  1. NPTEL, System, Surroundings and Properties: Types of systems: closed, open, and isolated systems and their exchange conditions; used only for physical definitions.
  2. NASA Glenn, Second Law–Entropy: verbal explanations of systems and surroundings and reversible and irreversible processes. Its equations were not used to calculate business outcomes; no physical experiment was conducted.
  3. World Bank, WGI official FAQ: governance dimensions, uses of aggregate indicators, and limits requiring detailed information. No country scores were retrieved, countries ranked, or particular investments or legal cases assessed.