During a Bible study at our church small group, the brother leading it posed a question: “How would you introduce God to someone who doesn’t know Him?”
Everyone took turns answering. “God is the omnipotent Creator.” “God is love.” “God is the righteous Judge.” “God is eternal and unchanging.”
Every answer was “correct.” If this were a theology exam, all of them would earn points.
But sitting there, I had a lingering question I couldn’t shake: If God can truly be fully described by these words, is He still God?
The Arrogance of Language
I can also mistake being able to say something for understanding it, and definition for possession. This is a habit of language I need to question in myself.
In everyday life, this works most of the time. When you say “this cup of coffee is hot,” you have indeed captured an important characteristic of the coffee. When you say “this company’s revenue is one billion,” you have indeed described a verifiable fact.
When language turns toward God, I ask not whether we may speak, but whether we have mistaken a finite description for complete understanding.
When we say “God is omnipotent,” we are actually framing God within the human understanding of “power.” But is God’s “omnipotence” the same thing as the “power” we understand? When we speak of “power,” what we picture in our minds is “the force to accomplish something.” But what if God’s “power” transcends all our imaginings of “force”?
If I assume my vocabulary already contains God, language can become a cage rather than a guide. Not every confession limits God; the reminder is not to mistake confession for control.
The Path of Apophatic Theology
Pseudo-Dionysius’s Mystical Theology offers a path for considering language’s limits. The text discusses affirmation alongside negation and ultimately points toward God beyond both. It cannot be reduced to allowing only “is not.”
For me, “God is not finite” can guard against reducing God to a finite thing. Yet “God is infinite” is not necessarily less honest. What matters is how I understand and use the statement, acknowledging that it cannot exhaust God.
The reminder I draw from this apophatic path is not to treat any set of descriptions as the endpoint. This does not claim that negation is the only way to know God, or that each “is not” guarantees a step toward truth. Neither affirmation nor negation entitles me to announce complete possession of God.
What concerns me is that a fixed image of God can also make me unwilling to examine my understanding. Relinquishing control need not abandon every confession; it can mean remaining willing to learn.
The Flood of Certainty
Why do I need this reminder within faith? In some discussions I have encountered, a clear answer can quickly become an answer that must not be questioned.
Direction and reassurance are not wrong. My concern is whether certainty replaces trust in God when reasons cannot be explained or examined. This reflects settings I have encountered, not the motives of every church.
I’ve spent many years in the church, and I’ve observed a pattern. Many people (including my own past self) equate “firmness of faith” with “being certain about everything.” I’m certain God exists. I’m certain His plan is good. I’m certain that every sentence in the Bible is literally true. I’m certain that my denomination’s interpretation of the Bible is correct.
These certainties provide immense psychological comfort. But they also create a closed system. Within this system, questioning equals unbelief, doubt equals weakness, and saying “I don’t know” equals insufficient faith.
In “Faith Collapse and Rebuilding,” I shared my own experience. The most important lesson that collapse taught me was this: a faith that cannot accommodate “I don’t know” is, in fact, fragile. Because its foundation is the feeling of certainty, not God Himself.
The Courage to Not Know
I do not reduce skepticism or agnosticism to “not knowing, so do not believe.” They raise philosophical questions that a slogan cannot replace.
In my own faith, acknowledging limited understanding can open further exploration. I still choose trust, without requiring others to follow the same path.
It took me a long time to reach this stage on my own journey of faith. When I was young, I needed certainty. I needed to know who God was, what He wanted me to do, and what the meaning of life was. Those answers gave me direction and a sense of security.
But as I grew older, with more experiences, more reading, and more reflection, I found those certain answers beginning to loosen. Not because my faith had grown weaker, but because I began to realize: those answers were merely the finger, not the moon. They pointed in a direction, but as for what lay at the end of that direction, I grew less and less willing to say I knew.
And strangely, this “not knowing” did not weaken my faith. It deepened it.
For me, letting go of “I already fully know what God is” makes room to face what I cannot control. That is one form of reverence as I understand it, not a qualification for judging whether someone else’s faith is real.
Being Silent Before Faith
Perhaps the most practical insight of apophatic theology is this: sometimes, before God, the best response is to be silent.
Not because there is nothing to say, but because we know: some things, the moment they are spoken, have already gone astray.
When I rush to settle every question, pausing to listen is a courage I need to practice. Silence is not therefore superior to every sermon; sometimes I also need to explain my reasons and take responsibility for my words.
I’m not saying that teaching and preaching are unimportant, of course they matter. But teaching and preaching should carry a fundamental humility: “I am using finite language to speak of the infinite God, so every word I say may not be entirely correct.”
I hope such humility reminds me not to confuse my definition with God. It still requires actual reflection: saying “I am limited” does not guarantee I will avoid the same mistakes.
God transcends definition. This is not the end of faith, but faith’s true beginning. And the posture at this beginning is not loudly declaring “I know,” but quietly acknowledging: “Before You, my language is not enough.”
In my faith, this kind of quiet can also become worship.
Leaving room within faith
Speak about God while acknowledging that our language remains incomplete.
An affirmative confession does not amount to complete possession of God.
Negation is no automatic guarantee of moving closer to truth.
Silence and speech both require listening, reasons, and responsibility.
Our own faith journey is not a ranking of other people’s devotion.
Keep trust, and leave room to continue understanding.
Revision and source boundaries: November 5, 2026. This revision checks chapters I, III, and V of C. E. Rolt’s translation of Mystical Theology, hosted by CCEL, distinguishing affirmation, negation, and transcendence of both. The website summary does not replace the translated text. The nonessential Eckhart attribution is withdrawn because the original sermon was not checked; this does not declare the quotation false. Small-group experiences and the faith journey remain the original author’s account, not a representation of every church, philosophical position, or theological tradition.


💬 Comments
Loading...