Timeline note. This piece retains reflections written in 2016 and later additions; the current page is dated May 27, 2023.
In 2014, my child’s mother and I made a decision that drew a lot of head-shaking from family and friends: we pulled our child out of school and enrolled them in non-school experimental education, what most people simply call homeschooling.
When we made the decision, my child was still young. The reactions around us followed a predictable pattern: “Are you sure about this?” “What about university admissions later?” “Won’t they fall out of step with society?”
Some people were more diplomatic about it. Others said it plainly: “Aren’t you being too idealistic?”
I don’t hold it against them. In Taiwan’s social context, “leaving school” carries an almost inherently rebellious charge, as though you’re repudiating the path everyone else has walked.
My entrepreneurial experience then left me with questions about changes in work and learning. I brought those questions to my child’s education: alongside existing knowledge, how could he practice facing new problems?
That was my concern at the time, not proof that conventional schooling’s content would become obsolete, and not an answer I could settle in advance for my child’s future.
The design and execution of this path was primarily my doing. My child’s mother supported it throughout, giving me the room to try.
Peeling Off the Romantic Label
I should say this clearly from the start: self-directed education is not a utopia.
Much of what you read online about homeschooling is too romantic. “Let children freely explore their gifts.” “Learning in nature.” “Innovation that breaks the mold.” These narratives sound beautiful. Walk into the reality, though, and you find it is full of grey, including real friction and conflict with your child.
The original records the following reflections in 2016; later additions also remain our family’s experience.
For our family, homeschooling requires accompaniment. Seeking support from an institution, consultant, or community does not mean parents stop caring about learning. The point is to think together: what are we learning today, why this, and what might it mean for the child’s future? This does not prescribe one division of responsibilities for every family.
I do not treat homeschooling as an admissions shortcut. Families with specific academic or learning goals need to understand the conditions, resources, and limitations of different paths before choosing. This experience cannot guarantee easier admission through conventional schooling or a more efficient diploma through homeschooling.
Homeschooling is a co-venture. This is the analogy I reach for most often. You and your child are running an educational enterprise together. The product is the curriculum; the user is your child. You do market research (understand their interests and capacities), develop the product (design the learning content), run user testing (observe how the child responds and grows), and iterate continuously (adjust based on what you learn).
The analogy also includes uncertainty. At the time, institutional arrangements did not mean every support our family needed was available. Communities and a child’s interests can change, requiring adjustment. Those experiences do not explain current application or student-status rules.
After so many years on this unconventional path, I’m reluctant to speak with too much certainty. Honestly, I often couldn’t see clearly what lay ahead. There was real confusion and doubt, even the fear that I might be harming my child. But confusion and commitment are not mutually exclusive. I never seriously considered turning back. It was more like a conviction that grew stronger precisely because the road ahead was unclear. Choosing a path with no footprints means accepting from the start that no one can guarantee the destination. You get lost, and you keep going.
For me, choosing homeschooling also includes reflection on life and education. Beyond success in established assessments, I hope my child gradually practices judging what deserves commitment. That is my educational value; choosing a form does not establish that the child already has the ability.
The Adults Who Fall Short
The hardest problems on the homeschool path aren’t curriculum design or learning pace. They are people.
Specifically: educators who are not up to the task.
Once, the children were participating together in a learning project. Work they had invested a great deal of time in was taken by the supervising teacher for commercial use, without asking us first. We found out later, when we saw it appear on social media.
My child was furious. It was the first time someone in a position of authority over him had done something he recognized as wrong. His response was immediate: “This is so unfair!”
I agreed completely. It was unfair.
With accompaniment and support, it also became an opportunity for us to practice expression. Such learning is not exclusive to homeschooling; it can occur inside or outside conventional schools.
Gentle, Courteous Resistance
I asked my child: You feel this is unfair, good. Your anger makes sense. But what do you plan to do about it?
You could stew in silence and curse that teacher a hundred times in your head. You could vent to friends and make sure everyone knows how bad he is. You could pretend nothing happened and tell yourself “keeping the peace matters more.”
Or you could do something harder and more valuable: get clear on what you think, and then say it to him, gently, politely, but without backing down.
I encouraged the last option. We worked together to organize the facts, walked through possible versions of the conversation, and thought through how to respond if he pushed back.
The process took several days. More time than any academic assignment had ever required.
Eventually, my child found the courage to go and talk to that teacher. What came out was probably about a third as strong as what we had practiced. But he said it. In his own words, he stated his position.
That moment felt a hundred times more important than scoring full marks on any exam.
The Muscle of Resistance
In my piece “Emotions Live in Relationships Too”, I wrote about how emotional intelligence isn’t built through individual practice alone. The relational dimension of EQ requires actual interaction with other people. The same is true of “resistance.” It isn’t innate. It is a muscle, and it has to be trained.
People who find it hard to speak about unfairness may have different concerns and constraints; we cannot attribute them all to a lack of practice or conventional education. In our family, I hope my child has room to organize his thoughts and knows he can seek support.
“Keeping the harmony” is a virtue in Taiwanese culture. But if harmony comes at the cost of suppressing every dissenting view and absorbing every injustice, then “harmony” is no longer harmony. It becomes a synonym for oppression.
What I want my child to learn is not “perpetual peace,” but “the ability to resist, gently and courteously, when resistance is called for.”
Gentle, because the goal is not to wound the other person but to express yourself. Courteous, because respect runs both ways, even when the other person hasn’t shown you any. And firm, because if you believe something is wrong, you have a responsibility to say so.
This was one concrete practice within our homeschooling experience. It does not prove homeschooling always offers more opportunities, or that a child should face unfairness alone or confront someone directly. Context, the child’s willingness, and available support matter; speaking once does not guarantee the ability is established.
Education Without a Right Answer
After all these years, the clearest thing I’ve learned is this: there is no single right answer in education.
Schools, communities, and families differ in resources, constraints, and practices. We value room to adjust in homeschooling, but that does not make every conventional school exam-driven or every homeschool experience necessarily deeper.
But whichever path you choose, the underlying question is the same: what kind of person are you trying to raise?
Good grades need not be separated from judgment, choice, and responsibility as two mutually exclusive paths. Inside or outside conventional schools, we can ask whether a child has opportunities to understand problems, express thoughts, and receive support.
Self-directed education is one way to do that. What matters is not the form but whether, within that form, you are bringing the real world into your child’s learning.
Including the uncomfortable parts. Including the adults who fall short. Including the unfair treatment. Including the moments that require you to stand up and say no.
I compare expressing disagreement to a muscle that needs practice. For children, practice also requires appropriate situations and accompaniment. It need not wait until adulthood, nor demand that they speak courageously every time.
Separating experience and judgment
When choosing an educational form, consider the support a child needs too.
One family’s experience cannot rank every educational path.
Parental accompaniment and outside support need not exclude each other.
Practicing disagreement belongs neither exclusively inside nor outside conventional schools.
Speaking once deserves appreciation, but does not guarantee an ability is established.
Help children practice expressing themselves and know they have support.
Revision and source boundaries: November 5, 2026. The original 2016 reflections, the current page’s 2023 date, and later additions remain distinct; no first-publication year is inferred. The original parent roles, child-teacher incident, and father’s preparation and conversation remain author accounts, without added identities, rights ownership, infringement findings, apologies, or outcomes. Universal educational-path rankings and admission guarantees are removed. This piece is not current legal guidance on experimental education, diplomas, or student status.


💬 Comments
Loading...