I remember once during college, chatting with a classmate about a mutual friend who didn’t get into graduate school. One classmate said, quite naturally, “He just didn’t work hard enough.”

At the time, that sentence sounded entirely reasonable. Because we ourselves had gotten in, we figured: we got in because we worked hard enough. He didn’t get in because he didn’t work hard enough. What a clear causal relationship.

Twenty years later, I know how arrogant that sentence was.

Not because that friend turned out fine. In fact, I don’t know how things went for him. But because I finally realized: my getting in was due, beyond hard work, to a hundred factors I couldn’t see at the time. I was born into a family that valued education, I had books to read from childhood, my health never interrupted my studies with any illness, and my financial situation allowed me to prepare for exams full-time without having to work part-time.

None of these did I “earn.” They were luck.

The Illusion of the Winner

I call the mindset that takes all the credit for success “the illusion of the winner.” In edited excerpts from a 2020 KCRW interview, Sandel also criticizes this attitude: taking success as entirely our own achievement can obscure contingency and our obligations to one another in a shared life.

The meritocratic narrative goes like this: society is fair, opportunity is open. As long as you’re smart enough and work hard enough, you can succeed. So the successful succeed because they deserve it. The failures fail because they aren’t good enough.

This narrative raises two concerns for me.

First, outcomes cannot be explained by individual effort alone. Family, educational opportunities, health, and institutions can affect which choices are available. We do not need to calculate one universal ratio between these factors and effort; the point is not to assume everyone has the conditions we received.

Second, I worry that this story can make successful people more prone to arrogance and lead those facing setbacks to blame themselves entirely.

Treating success as entirely deserved can obscure other people’s constraints. Treating failure as entirely deserved can leave institutions and conditions unquestioned. These are tendencies to watch for, not inevitable reactions in everyone who succeeds or struggles.

This way of interpreting outcomes can deepen estrangement between people; I do not treat it as the single root of social conflict.

The Taiwanese Version of Meritocracy

Looking back at my upbringing, I recognize the success narrative built around advancement and credentials.

That narrative links advancement, credentials, jobs, and wages into an upward ladder. But exams and school reputation do not independently determine everyone’s work, and salary does not fully determine a person’s social value.

This path looks fair. Everyone takes the same questions, and those with higher scores advance. But “the same questions” obscures one fact: the people sitting in the exam hall came in with completely different starting lines.

Some people have more learning resources; others balance study with work or family responsibilities. These conditions can affect preparation time and choices, but a home address alone does not tell us what resources a family has.

Then we look at the exam results and say: “See, fair competition, the best people rose to the top.”

Identical exam questions cannot by themselves settle whether preparation conditions were fair. That is the question I want to pursue.

The Meritocratic Myth in Startup Circles

I see the same logic in startup circles, just with a different packaging.

“Hard work guarantees success” becomes “As long as you have enough execution, enough vision, enough willingness to sacrifice, you can build your company up.”

I myself once believed in this. In the early days of my startup, I did work extremely hard. Working over ten hours a day, thinking about the company on weekends too, putting health and family behind. The company survived, and I thought: it was my hard work that kept it alive.

But honestly, among the reasons the company survived, “the timing was right” and “good luck” probably accounted for a larger share than I’d care to admit. I entered a growing market at the right moment, I encountered a few clients willing to give me a chance, and my team had a few people much stronger than me who held the line at critical moments.

Crediting all this to “my hard work” is like standing on the crest of a wave and saying, “I made the sea rise.”

And what about the entrepreneurs who failed? They might have worked just as hard as me, or even harder. But their timing was a little off, their luck a little worse, or at some critical moment they lacked a benefactor. The meritocratic narrative would say: “They failed, so something must not have been good enough.” But the fact might simply be: the dice didn’t land on the right side.

The Unfair Pressure on the Younger Generation

Let me turn the focus to the younger generation.

When discussing young people’s pressures, I want to ask about opportunities and constraints alongside effort. Individual choices still matter; both levels deserve attention.

Concrete comparisons of housing, wages, education, and jobs require dates, locations, and consistent measures. A few generalizations cannot replace that evidence. My ethical question is whether, when a young person experiences setbacks, we are too quick to ask only what they did wrong.

“I didn’t work hard enough.” “I chose the wrong major.” “I’m not capable enough.”

This is the cruelest part of meritocracy. It turns a problem of structure into a personal sin. In “The Immoral Society, the Moral Individual”, I discussed Niebuhr’s view: an individual can be moral, but social structures can be immoral. To blame the individual for consequences produced by an immoral structure is a systematic injustice.

A Faith Perspective: Grace vs. Merit

As someone with a background in theological training, I see in Sandel’s argument a very familiar theme.

Christian theology has a core concept called “grace”: your existence, your abilities, your opportunities are not “earned” by you, but “given” to you. You are a recipient, not a self-made achiever.

This concept directly conflicts with meritocracy. Meritocracy says: you are the architect of your own destiny. Grace says: the ground you stand on is not of your making.

I’m not saying everyone must be a Christian to understand this. But I believe the concept of “grace”, acknowledging that much in our lives was not earned by ourselves, is an important antidote to elite arrogance.

When you acknowledge that a large part of your success was luck and given opportunity, it becomes hard to tell a failure “it’s your own problem.” You begin to feel: since I have received so much, what responsibility do I have toward this society?

Redefining Contribution

What I take from this reading is an emphasis on dignity at work and shared contribution, rather than a sentence claiming to summarize Sandel’s complete institutional program.

Caring for older people, repairing roads, working night shifts, and farming all deserve respect. In my view, wage differences cannot fully answer what a job contributes to our shared life.

The real way forward isn’t to have everyone compete for National Taiwan University, start companies, or chase that position at the top of the pyramid. It’s to build a society where every job is respected, not just in words, but in real respect in terms of wages, institutions, and culture.

This goal sounds far off. But its starting point is very near: every person who recognizes that their success wasn’t entirely earned by themselves is the beginning of change.

Elite arrogance concerns personal attitudes as well as how institutions distribute opportunity and dignity. Personal reflection and institutional improvement need not exclude each other. It starts with acknowledging the role of luck, with respecting different forms of contribution. And one more thing: stop telling young people “you just didn’t work hard enough.”

Separating experience and judgment

Looking back at success, notice the conditions alongside effort.

Effort deserves recognition, but cannot explain everyone’s outcomes on its own.

Identical exam questions do not mean identical preparation conditions.

Wage differences cannot fully rank the social value of work.

Personal reflection still needs to connect with institutions and shared responsibility.

Less hasty blame, and more respect for different contributions.

Four-panel comic: Looking back at success, notice the conditions alongside effort. Effort deserves recognition, but cannot explain everyone’s outcomes on its own. Identical exam questions do not mean identical preparation conditions. Wage differences cannot fully rank the social value of work. Personal reflection still needs to connect with institutions and shared responsibility. Less hasty blame, and more respect for different contributions.

Revision and source boundaries: November 5, 2026. This revision checks edited excerpts from Sandel’s 2020 KCRW interview, not the full book word for word. “The illusion of the winner” is the author’s wording. Comparisons without common measures, cross-generation starting wages, and occupational salaries without defined scope are removed; psychological tendencies are not presented as inevitable. College and startup stories remain the original author’s accounts. Private records, the friend’s later life, and current labor-market data were not rechecked.