TL;DR — The church’s response to AI cannot be graded simply as fast or slow. An institution publishing a document, a pastor using a tool, and a local community being prepared are different things. A surveyed willingness to trust is also not evidence that core judgment has already been outsourced. What I want to preserve is the authority to judge rhythm: people and communities should decide which work can be accelerated and which forms of understanding and accompaniment need time.
I once found it easy to understand this moment through the claim that “the church cannot keep up with AI.” After seeing discussions of institutional documents, courses, and tool use, I came to think that the claim was too simple.
Some people beginning to use a tool does not mean that everyone is prepared. Someone expressing reservations is not necessarily afraid of technology. I am not asking who is running fastest, but which boundaries need to be made clear once tools enter the life of faith.
Institutional Response, Individual Use, and Community Readiness Need to Be Separated
At a minimum, “the church” includes three different levels: institutions, individual pastors, and local communities. A document can offer direction, and a course can teach operations; neither alone proves that every local church has developed criteria suited to its own situation.
For example, on May 25, 2026, the Holy See Press Office announced Magnifica Humanitas, explaining that the encyclical signed by Leo XIV concerned the protection of the human person in the age of AI. This confirms one institutional response. It cannot answer for the practices of every denomination and local community. This essay does not claim to provide a complete analysis of the encyclical on the basis of that announcement.
I also no longer place a few dates from the histories of printing and AI side by side and use them to calculate how much faster the church responded this time. The technologies, institutions, and questions of the two periods differ; their timelines cannot serve as a common measuring stick. I discuss the history of printing and the Reformation separately in The Reformation beyond One Hero: Faith, Printing, and Politics.
A more useful question for me is this: after the documents and courses, do local communities know what to do when an error appears? Do users know which material still needs to be checked?
Before Comparing 48% and 12%, Look at the Populations
A public Barna report from May 2026 brought together two surveys. The 48% figure refers to practicing Christians who said they would fully or partially trust AI advice about spiritual growth. The 12% figure refers to surveyed U.S. Protestant pastors. The adult survey was conducted in November 2025 with 1,514 respondents. The pastor survey was conducted in December with 442 respondents. These are not the same samples, and they are not percentages of Taiwanese churchgoers.
The original draft incorrectly described the 48% as representing all U.S. adults. The figures also cannot prove that people willing to use AI have already replaced pastoral care with it, nor can trust and use rates from different samples be stacked together to claim that the same group contradicts itself.
Asking a tool to revise one sentence and handing spiritual judgment over to it are different degrees of reliance. A survey can point us toward useful questions, but it cannot substitute for understanding actual uses.
The questions I want to retain are: In which situations are people willing to trust AI? After adoption, who is responsible for checking the output and responding to errors? Asking these questions clearly is more useful than describing the gap with a multiplier.
Do Not Decide the Defaults of Every Model in Advance
Whether one response mentions religion cannot, on its own, tell us how a model treats faith. The wording of the question, the model version tested, the supplied material, and the evaluation method can all affect the result.
The original draft cited a study without providing a direct source and then claimed that nearly every model silenced faith. I do not have enough evidence to support that generalization, so this version withdraws both the research account and the universal conclusion.
I still believe that, when choosing a tool, we should pay attention to how it organizes an answer and which perspectives tend to be absent. But that requires concrete examination. We cannot decide the motives of every system in advance or treat an answer as reliable merely because its tone is gentle.
The Slowness I Hope For Leaves Time for Understanding
I am a founder, and I use AI extensively in my work. I know the benefits of rapid production, and I also know how easily I can be carried along by the speed of output. This is a reflection on my own use, not a rule that models necessarily change every few weeks.
Reading a passage of scripture, listening to another person’s difficulty, and clarifying disagreement within a community all require time for me. Tools can help organize material, but the time required to generate an answer cannot substitute for the time people need to understand and accept it.
I call the willingness to leave time for these things a counter-rhythmic practice. This is the faith reflection of this essay. I no longer support it with an unverified speaker quotation or an account of the origin of acedia, nor do I claim that every church has preserved slowness in the same way for two thousand years.
A church can also become busy with events, courses, attendance, and visibility. Before criticizing acceleration outside the church, I would rather ask my own community whether we have preserved room for Sabbath, questions, and reconsideration.
Where Should the Authority to Judge Rhythm Remain?
In From the Royal Society to AI Collaboration: Who Checks After Generation?, I discussed the need for verification after generation. Here I want to ask one further question: Which work is suited to acceleration, when should we stop, and who has the authority to decide?
Organizing information, translation, and administrative work can benefit from tools after verification. Interpretation, relationships, and responsibility in pastoral care require separate human arrangements. Not every use of a tool is outsourcing, and slowing down does not automatically produce depth.
Guidance for use should not be postponed indefinitely. A local community can begin by clarifying which data may be entered, how citations should be verified, and who handles errors. It can also decide how to bring people back into the process when accompaniment and communal discernment are needed. The specific arrangements should be discussed in the context of each community rather than prescribed by this essay as one rule for every church.
By the authority to judge rhythm, I mean preserving the right of people and communities to adjust the purpose, speed, and boundaries of use. A tool can offer suggestions, but speed alone should not allow it to decide which work is worth doing.
Has the Meaning Ripened?
A sermon may have a first draft, but verification, theological reflection, and understanding of the community still remain. The quality of generated material is worth discussing, but it cannot make those questions disappear.
For me, trust and consolation are not completed simply by delivering a passage of text. When someone has lost a loved one, I still hope that another person will listen, remain present, and accept responsibility for what they say.
I hope the church preserves this kind of time while also retaining the ability to learn new tools. Neither speed nor slowness is sufficient evidence of the quality of faith; what matters is whether we remain willing to discern and take responsibility for our choices. Further discussion appears under Civilization and Humanity.


💬 Comments
Loading...